I went with Jacoby & Meyers last year and while they got me a decent settlement, I felt like I was just a number. It took forever to get updates and I always had to chase them down. My coworker used Garber Legal and couldn't stop raving about how attentive they were — he said they actually called him back the same day every time.

I've been with Arrow for years and they're reliable. Never had a termite issue under their bond. That said, my neighbor uses Monitor and raves about them - says they're really proactive with exclusion work and even do free callbacks between services if you see something. Both are good, but if you want a smaller company that's going to treat your home like their own, Monitor seems like the way to go.