Loading…
10
Watching my neighbor's dog respond to gentle guidance made me reflect on harsh corrections from the past
I was visiting my aunt last week, and she still uses a rolled-up newspaper to scold her schnauzer. It took me back to when that was the NORM, and dogs lived in fear. Now, with reward-based methods, I see pups EAGER to learn and bond. The shift from dominance theory to cooperation feels like a MASSIVE leap forward for animal welfare. It's heartening to witness this evolution in our understanding.
4 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In4 Comments
margaret_robinson737mo ago
Yikes, @phoenixwood's story hits home, because my buddy's shepherd used to cower at raised voices but became a totally different, goofy dog once they switched to clicker training.
10
phoenixwood7mo ago
Man, a friend's rescue Rottweiler would flinch if you even picked up a magazine. That dog had clearly been ruled by that old-school newspaper method, and seeing her learn to trust through treats and patience was night and day. It's wild how much happier and more confident she became.
4
the_angela7mo ago
The history of some breeds, like many herding dogs, is a partnership built on subtle communication and mutual trust to do a job. Harsh corrections literally rewired that genetic blueprint for cooperation into one of fear and suspicion. Modern positive methods feel less like 'new tricks' and more like finally speaking a language the dog was bred to understand for centuries. It’s not just kinder, it’s honoring the original working relationship we asked them for.
3