Tried the crunchy peanut butter instead of creamy and I'm shook

I've been Team Creamy my whole life, but the store was out so I grabbed crunchy on a whim. That extra texture in my sandwich today actually worked, like little flavor bombs. Anyone else have a brand switch that backfired?

2 comments

2 Comments

jasonallen5d ago

Totally feel you on the texture thing. I tried switching from my usual Skippy to that fancy organic stuff once and it was like eating gritty sand mixed with sadness. Never again, back to the cheap stuff for me.

parkerbrown5d ago

Are you telling me I'm not the only one who's been burned by the fancy peanut butter trap? I tried that once too, thought I was being healthy, and ended up with a jar of expensive disappointment that tasted like cardboard dust. Never again, Skippy and Jif are the only way to go.