Loading…
23
Unpopular opinion: my grandma's hand mixer beats the stand mixer for most everyday baking
I grew up watching my grandma make everything with a $20 hand mixer she bought at a hardware store in Fresno back in 1989, and I always figured she was just stuck in her ways. When I moved into my first apartment I saved up and bought a shiny stand mixer, convinced it would change my baking. After about 6 months I noticed something odd, my cakes and quick breads were coming out denser than hers ever did. So one Saturday I pulled out her old hand mixer and made the same banana bread recipe side by side. The hand mixer batch came out lighter and more even, and I think it's because I actually pay attention to the batter instead of walking away while the machine does the work. There's also something to be said for stopping when it looks right instead of letting a motor run for 3 minutes straight. I still use the stand mixer for stiff doughs and big batches, but for muffins and cakes the cheap little hand mixer wins most days. Anyone else find that a simpler tool actually gives them better results in the kitchen?
1 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In1 Comment
miller.emery1mo ago
You hit on something that most people miss, which is that the tool actually forces you to stay in the moment with what you're making. When I use the hand mixer I'm standing right there, watching the batter come together, feeling the drag of the beaters, stopping the second it looks right. With the stand mixer it's way too easy to just turn it on and go check my phone or start wiping counters, and then the batter's been going for four minutes past when it should've stopped. Overmixing is the real killer for muffins and quick breads, it makes them tough and tunnel-y, and a machine that runs on its own schedule instead of yours will absolutely do that to you. Your grandma's mixer probably has less power too, which sounds like a bad thing but actually means it folds the flour in slower and gentler instead of whipping the life out of it. So it's not just nostalgia or being old school, there's a real mechanical reason the cheap little thing wins sometimes. The stand mixer earns its keep for cookie dough and bread, no question, but for anything where you're trying to keep the crumb light, your own two eyes on the bowl beat a motor every time.
5